parking tickets

Subscribe by Email

Your email:

"Larry's Blog" is now available on your Kindle!

nypt-amazon-com-logo-fancier-150
Simply "Click" on the image above.

Follow Larry

ALPHABETICAL INDEX TO LARRY'S BLOG

Loading

Larry's Blog

Current Articles | RSS Feed RSS Feed

Customer Success: Fight Fire Hydrant Parking Ticket and Win!

  
 

A New York Parking Ticket LLC customer success story

It is great to witness the adjudication process for fighting a NYC parking ticket for a Code 40: Fire Hydrant violation working perfectly.

The Facts

Joe parks his car on a NYC street, more than 15 feet from a fire hydrant. When he returns to his vehicle, he sees that all too familiar orange envelope under his windshield. His heart starts beating faster, and his face turns red. He reads the parking ticket charging a violation of Code 40. The parking ticket warrior's sworn comment on the front of the parking ticket says Joe's car is parked only 6 feet from the hydrant.  Joe's reaction is anger, outrage and a commitment to fight the parking ticket because he is right.

The NYC Parking Rules and Regulations

Code 40 prohibits:

"Stopping, standing or parking within 15 feet of a fire hydrant.  Between sunrise and sunset, a passenger vehicle may stand alongside a fire hydrant as long as the operator remains behind the wheel and is ready to move the vehicle if required to do so"

Chapter 4-08(e). No person shall stop, stand or park a vehicle in any of the following places...

"(2) Hydrants.  Within fifteen feet of a fire hydrant, unless otherwise indicated by signs, or parking meters, except that during the period from sunrise to sunset if standing is not otherwise prohibited, the operator of a passenger car may stand the vehicle alongside a fire hydrant provided that the operator remains in the operator's set ready for immediate operation of the vehicle at all times and starts the motor of the car on hearing the approach of fire apparatus, and provided further, that the operator shall immediately remove the car from alongside the fire hydrant when instructed to do so by any member of the police, fire, or other municipal department acting in his/her official capacity"

Joe's Action

Joe:

  • Always carries a tape measure and camera with him in his car
  • Asks a witness to assist him in measuring the distance between the fire hydrant and his car
  • Takes a number of dated photos that clearly demonstrate his car was parked more than 15 feet from the fire hydrant
  • Hires New York Parking Ticket LLC to fight his parking ticket

Outcome

  • We prepare detailed Affidavits for execution by Joe and his witness
  • Send a defense letter, detailed Affidavits, photographs confirming the facts contained in the Affidavits; along with the signed NYC parking ticket to the address on the back of the parking ticket
  • Enter a plea of NOT GUILTY and request a hearing by mail
  • Approximately four weeks later, Joe receives a letter from the DOF advising him that his parking ticket is dismissed

Photographs

fight new york parking ticket, parking ticket nyc

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

nyc parking ticket law, beat nyc parking ticket

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

parking ticket, parking ticket nyc

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Commentary

A $3.00 tape measure saved Joe $115. When you are right, fight your NYC parking ticket. You can see the power of a photograph and tape measure.  The NYC parking ticket hearing official did the right thing after reviewing the evidence, which is really nice to see.

How about the NYC parking ticket warrior?  She clearly lied about the distance from the fire hydrant and got caught. Shame on you! 

In response to a frequently asked question, the fact that a parking ticket warrior fails to accurately state the distance from your car to the fire hydrant is not enough to win a dismissal. You must prove that your vehicle was parked MORE than 15 feet from the fire hydrant.

I went out and purchased a tape measure. How about you?

[Editor's note: "Joe" is a fictitious name to protect the privacy of our client. "Joe" gave us permission to tell his success story and publish the photographs]

nyc fire hydrant parking ticket, parking ticketPlease tell us your success story. It helps all of us to share information about NYC parking tickets

 

 

If you found this article helpful, you may wish to share it with your friends. Simply click on the above social media buttons of your choice. Thanks, Larry

Comments

Hi ! I live in Montreal. Last weekend I've been to New-York and didn't know about that 15 feet distance from fire hydrant and got a ticket. I was 5 feets from the hydrant (which is the distance required here in Montreal). What can I do !? Should I not pay the ticket and hope not get cought next time I'm in New-York with that car ? What are my options ? Thanks a lot for that great article, I'll know what to do next time !
Posted @ Thursday, August 20, 2009 6:17 PM by Oliver
I also parked my car more than 15ft from a fire hydrant in NY and received a ticket saying it was only 9ft.I went to a hearing and the Judge ignored the evidence that was in the photos and found me guilty.He said that I was parked about 20ft from the fire hydrant and could not understand why an officer would write 9ft.He told me he did not believe my testimony no matter what the pictures prove.The whole process took 3minutes I was not sworn in nor was my testimony recorded which is the nor.I will appeal the decision can you advice how to proceed so I can get this overturned. I have not made a payment yet. Thanks!Silvia 
Posted @ Friday, September 18, 2009 10:27 PM by Silvia
What if you were parked 15 feet and your car was towed? ANd they wrote 6 feet on the ticket?  
 
 
 
Posted @ Monday, November 02, 2009 7:30 PM by Laura
Hi, I have the similar case. The officer wrote on the ticket the car was parked 8 feet from the hydrant. I took 18 pictures and measured the distance, it was 16 feet. I sent everything through mail and it shows on the website it is guilty, and the result is not mailed back.
Posted @ Tuesday, November 10, 2009 12:29 AM by Russ
Russ, 
Thank you for visiting our website and sharing your parking ticket experience. 
 
I am very sorry to hear that you lost your dispute. You do have a right to appeal within 30 days of the decision. 
 
Let me pose some questions: 
1. Were the photographs time/dated? 
2. Did you assert your defense in an affidavit? 
3. Did any of your photographs include the address of the location where you received your parking ticket? 
4. Did you provide a witness statement? 
 
I am happy to review your defense statement and photographs and advise you my opinion of your chances of success on appeal; or suggest what may have been missing. Our email address is nyparkingticket@optonline.net 
 
Posted @ Tuesday, November 10, 2009 9:05 AM by Larry Berezin
I sent you my case in the email nyparkingticket@optonline.net Please review it
Posted @ Friday, December 18, 2009 4:18 PM by Vikki
Hello, Larry, 
 
I'm so glad I've read your blog. Since two days ago, when I got fire hydrant parking ticket, I already knew what to do. Thank you! I got the ticket stating that I was parked 8 feet away from the hydrant, where as in reality I was 16 feet away. I had measuring tape and photo camera with me, so I took pictures of my car parked and measuring tape from my car to the hydrant. But I got two questions: 1. How to write the statement that I'm pleading not guilty, meaning can you provide any examples of such letter (it's ok if you cannot). 
2. More importantly, what's better to send the form, statement and evidence via mail or come in person? I mean can they dismiss a ticket right away if you come in person or they would still appoint a hearing? 
Thank you!
Posted @ Tuesday, December 29, 2009 9:29 AM by Dariya
I received a ticket for parking by a fire hydrant. I wanted to dispute the ticket and get the reduced fine online but the ticket was entered online after 30 days of issuance so it is already past due. It there anything i can do? 
 
It was issued on 11/20 and was not visible online until 12/22
Posted @ Tuesday, December 29, 2009 11:41 AM by D'Raj
D'Raj d, 
May I call you D'Raj? Thanks for taking your valuable time to stop by our web site. I hope you found the information helpful. 
 
I'm sorry to advise that the DOF does not offer a reduction for a fire hydrant violation. I suggest you look at the face of your parking ticket for mistakes. If not, then can assert any of the exceptions? 
 
If not, you may have to bit the parking ticket bullet and pay your fine before being hit with additional penalties. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Thursday, December 31, 2009 10:08 AM by Larry Berezin
Hi, 
I was hit with a $115 ticket. I did not intentially park infront of the hydrant. The car broke dwn and me and the tow driver was under the hood. The ticket officer came from behind and did not pay attention to the situation with given explanation from both parties. She then scanned my registration. I argued with her and even have a tow bill. Can I fight this ticket?
Posted @ Friday, January 15, 2010 7:34 AM by cheryl hoskins
Cheryl, 
Thank you for visiting our website and posting a very important question. Yours is a great example of what happens when a violation collides with a defense.  
 
When you're right-FIGHT. The "disabled vehicle" defense applies to your situation. You will find information on our blog about how to apply the defense. 
 
Please keep us posted. 
Good luck! 
 
Posted @ Friday, January 15, 2010 8:35 AM by Larry Berezin
Hi, 
 
I just received a notice in the mail for a $125 ticket for parking at a fire hydrant (+ late fee).  
I remember the incident, I was in the car and a NYPD parking Toyota Prius pulled along side. I turned on my headlights to show I was in the car and he didn't move. I proceeded to move the car and he then followed me a block or two then drove away. 
I never received any notice of a ticket prior to this. Is this legal? What should I do?
Posted @ Thursday, January 21, 2010 1:35 PM by Joe
Joe 
Thanks for taking your valuable time to visit our website and post your very interesting question. NYC parking rules permit you to stand/park alongside a fire hydrant as long as a licensed driver sits behind the wheel ready to move your vehicle upon request, BETWEEN SUNRISE & SUNSET. 
 
When you mentioned you turned the headlights on, does that mean you parked after sunset? If so, the parking ticket is properly issue. 
If not, I recommend you fight your parking ticket. 
 
Did you check the front of your parking ticket for omitted, misdescribed or illegible required elements? 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Thursday, January 21, 2010 2:46 PM by Larry Berezin
dear larry 
 
I received a traffic ticket of a code 40, which means parking next to the hydrant, and they stated i was 7 feet away from it. the ticket was issued to me at 1:22am on Feb 3, 2010. The address was stated at C/O of henry and poplar street. I actually parked on henry street and about 15 feet away from the hydrant., more importantly i have seen people parking on the same spot all the time. The question is the way they stated the address, because i actually parked behind one car, which was parked C/O henry and poplar street, and if i take that address, i m clearly 30 feet away from the hydrant. 
What is your advice on this case? 
 
thanks in advance!!! 
yuyu
Posted @ Sunday, February 07, 2010 12:15 AM by yu yu choi
YuYu 
Thanks for visiting our website and sharing your parking experience. It means a lot to us. 
Place of occurrence is a required element and must be described accurately. If not, your parking ticket is dismissible upon application. 
 
C/O is not an accurate way to describe place of occurrence. You win! Congratulations. 
 
Did you take photographs of your car in the space where you were ticketed? If not, you may not be able to prove the distance you parked from the hydrant exceeded 15 feet. 
 
Anyway, in this instance, it doesn't seem to matter because you have a misdescribed required element to beat your ticket. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Sunday, February 07, 2010 8:17 AM by Larry Berezin
I received a ticket for parking in front of a hydrant that I did not see. The area was under construction and the scaffolding blocked the street lamps, the scaffolding support blocked the view of the hydrant itself, the hydrant was covered in dust as the surrounding area, obscuring it. The hydrant also had no flourescent or colored paint on it, just the matte metallic color. And neither the curb nor the street had any paint or markings indicating the hydrant. I submitted photos but was rejected and would like to appeal. Are there regulations requiring such markings or clear visibility to make this a valid summons?
Posted @ Tuesday, February 09, 2010 12:15 AM by Stuart
Stuart 
Great question. Unfortunately, there are no such regulations. It seems the DOF adheres to an existential fire hydrant policy, i.e, if it exists, it is, and you can be ticketed. 
 
Thanks for taking your valuable time to visit our website. The DOF is inflexible with fire hydrant cases because of the dangers posed by a blocked hydrant in the event of a fire. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Tuesday, February 09, 2010 6:21 AM by Larry Berezin
Hi,  
 
I received not one, but two, parking tixs for parking too close to a fire hydrant. The tixs say 7 feet. I measured and I have to admit that it wasn't 15 feet, but 13. However, it seems crazy that I'd be issued 2 tixs (each one day after the other) . The only mistake on one tix was that they put the wrong precinct. Is it worth trying to get them to dismiss at least 1 ticket?  
This, btw, is in a spot where there's more than 15 feet between the hydrant and the corner and no cars parked. But I know that argument won't hold with a judge. Thanks! 
Sue
Posted @ Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:57 AM by sue
Sue 
Thanks for visiting our website and posing a very important question. NYC is inflexible when it comes to fire hydrant violations because of the safety issues involved. It matters not that the warrior's estimate is wrong; if you cannot prove you parked more than 15 feet away. 
 
The DOF will find you guilty for parking within 15 feet of an invisible fire hydrant covered with snow, or a broken fire hydrant. There is no offer of a reduced fine. 
 
Best advice is to stay away. Ties and close calls go to the DOF. 
 
Good luck
Posted @ Thursday, February 11, 2010 1:57 PM by Larry Berezin
Hi there... A couple of days ago I got zapped with a No Standing ticket. I did spot an error on the ticket as the precinct indicated is wrong. Do I have any recourse being that there is an error on the ticket or should I just pay it and get it over with???
Posted @ Friday, February 26, 2010 9:03 PM by John
John 
Here are Larry's Rules to Park by: 
1. When you're right-FIGHT 
2. When you did the crime, apply for a reduced fine__on-line. 
3. Never, ever violate the parking rules against parking within 15 feet of a fire hydrant; parking in a handicap space; or parking in front of a 4 corner pedestrian ramp. Heavy fines, no reduction 
4. Never, ever fight a parking ticket on-line.  
5. Never, ever wait 2 hours at the DOF for a hearing on a NYC parking ticket when you did the crime and you're only seeking a reduced fine. You can apply for a reduced fine, on-line. 
 
There are a couple of additional Rules, but it's 10:02 p.m. and I'm going to catch the Olympics. Oh, almost forgot...Precinct is not a required element entitling you to a dismissal upon application. 
 
Any other mistakes? Were you stopping temporarily to drop-off or pick-up a passenger? 
 
If you answers are "none of the above"...Follow Rule #2. 
 
Thanks for sharing your excellent question. Come back soon, John.
Posted @ Saturday, February 27, 2010 9:06 PM by Larry Berezin
Steve 
Commercial break...I almost forgot the most important RULE:  
Always, absolutely every time you receive a NYC parking ticket, check for mistakes on the front of the ticket. If you find an omitted, misdescribed or illegible required element, you are entitled to a dismissal of your ticket upon application.  
 
I've listed the 10 required elements in other blog posts. 
 
Good luck. 
Posted @ Saturday, February 27, 2010 9:14 PM by Larry Berezin
Hi, Larry, 
 
I am glad I found your blog. I am new to NJ  
 
from mid-west area. I got a parking ticket in  
 
NYC for 0 feet from fire hydrant. I have been  
 
very careful for reading the parking signs in  
 
NYC. However, I am not aware about the rule of 15 ft away from fire hydrant.  
 
Chapter 4-08(e). No person shall stop, stand or park a vehicle in any of the following places... 
 
"(2) Hydrants. Within fifteen feet of a fire hydrant, unless otherwise indicated by signs, or parking meters
 
My question is what signs and parking meters are exceptions.  
 
Where I parked, there is a sign  
 
clearly says "No Parking 8-9:30 AM Monday- 
 
Thursday" for both forward and backward  
 
dirction of the sign.  
 
It was a Sunday, so I parked there right by the sign (backward). That's a very short one way street. If 15 ft from the hydrant apllies here, basically no one can park backward direction from the sign. And the sign should change to one direction only. It is very confusing sing for me. 
 
Can I defense the ticket based on this?
Posted @ Sunday, February 28, 2010 5:44 PM by Jerry
Help please!! I parked 17 feet away from a hydrant, and apparently the minute i walked away i was towed. The ticket says 7 feet. Is there any way to try and fight this?
Posted @ Wednesday, March 24, 2010 9:47 AM by Helen
I have lived near the spot of my ticket, 120th and Claremont, for over 15 years and know the parking rules well, which is why I DID NOT park closer than 15 feet from a hydrant. To make matters worse, the vehicle is my mother's car that I've borrowed, with out-of-state plates, and suspect this is why a parking warrior tagged me with a "6 feet from hydrant" bogus ticket. The ticket was issued at 9:33 am, and my car was immediately towed so no pictures were available. My blood boiled when I discovered my missing car. What can I do? It will cost me more to miss work than pay the $300+, but this just ain't right, picking on "tourists" or whomever is gullible enough to park on corrupt NYC streets. Please advise!!!
Posted @ Thursday, March 25, 2010 4:17 PM by Nick
In the space to list type of vehicle, it says SUBN. My car is a minivan. Will they dismiss it based on that? 
 
Second, someone from out of town borrowed my car and parked there. Am I still responsible for his parking?
Posted @ Friday, April 09, 2010 10:40 AM by Blitz
Blitz 
Thanks for taking your valuable time and visiting our website. Great question. Is your vehicle registered in NY? If so, what does the registration say?  
 
Unfortunately, you are responsible for the parking tickets earned by a person to whom you "loaned" your car. 
 
Let me know what your reg says.  
Thanks.
Posted @ Monday, April 19, 2010 12:17 PM by Larry Berezin
So sorry for missing your comment; as well as the three others. Great question. A parking ticket warrior is required to insert the distance your vehicle was from the pump. It does not have to be accurate.  
 
Makes sense? Of course not. But, if you were within the pump zone of 15 feet, you can't beat a parking ticket for fire hydrant, unless there was a licensed driver behind the wheel ready to move your car upon request to do so between sunrise and sunset.  
 
Thanks.
Posted @ Monday, April 19, 2010 12:38 PM by Larry Berezin
Nick 
Please believe me when I say you are not alone. Your story is one of many parking ticket atrocities committed daily by some irresponsible parking ticket warriors. 
 
It pains me to say, without a photograph or witness, I can't think of a way to beat the NYC cocktail (ticket and tow). Sorry about that. 
 
I apologize profusely for overlooking your comment. I'm really losing it. Sorry!
Posted @ Monday, April 19, 2010 12:43 PM by Larry Berezin
My story is similar to the one above (120th & Claremont). I was parked on Claremont just north of 122nd St. more than 15 feet from a hydrant. My car was ticketed and towed with the violation stating that I was parked 5 feet from a hydrant. I appealed by mail and the appeal was denied. My building superintendent told me that the same thing almost happened to him. However, he was present when they were about to ticket his car. He asked the officer what was the problem and the reply was that the car was too  
 
close to the hydrant. The super demonstated that the distance was over 17 feet by pacing it with his feet. The officer apologized and proceeded on his way. This clearly  
 
indicates that this outrage is a pattern that could be citywide. I consulted with my State Assemblyman's office and they supported my decision to make a second appeal. I will let you know how this turns out. This is a serious situation and the media should be alerted to what is going on. I appreciate this blog as  
 
a a valuable tool for achieving justice.
Posted @ Wednesday, April 28, 2010 9:36 PM by Norman Curtis
Norman 
Thank you for taking your valuable time to visit our website and post your alarming story. You are not alone in this parking ticket scam. 
 
I will publish an article about this on our blog and alert the driving public. Let's see if we can incite some action to right this wrong. 
 
Posted @ Thursday, April 29, 2010 12:30 PM by Larry Berezin
Well, I got a ticket & a tow yesterday in nyc. Lucky me! The ticket states 6 feet from hydrant. Its hard to describe this spot that I have been parking at for over a year now without ever getting one ticket for it. The street corner kind of comes to a triangle. There is a fire hydrant there and enough room for one car to park. There are markings on the street pavement, a solid white box that extends from the pedestrian curb to maybe 3 feet from the hydrant. I always park closest to the curb & furthest from the hydrant. The car was probably not 15 feet from the hydrant, but I definetly always stay within the markings on the pavement. The spot is on Christopher & West Street, the sign there is a one way & yeild to pedestrian, nothing pertaining to parking, but I do still obey to the street sign on the previous block for the alternate side of the the street parking rules. Like I said, one year parking here and never a ticket! Also on the ticket is not a direct location of occurrence, it states: opposite 180 Christopher St. & under complainants comments it says: no permit, no driver, no activity (not sure what this means). Do you think I have any shot here of trying to fight this ticket if I send in pictures showing the markings on the pavement? (any chance of getting reimbursed the $185 it cost to get my car back?!) Thank you for any help!
Posted @ Saturday, May 01, 2010 9:05 AM by Eileen
Eileen 
I feel your pain. The parking ticket warriors lull you into thinking it's safe, when it isn't. 
 
Lets start with the parking rule. You can never, ever, under any circumstances except one, park within 15 feet of a fire hydrant....period. The big but is you are permitted to park within the 15 feet zone, IF YOU LEAVE A LICENSED DRIVER BEHIND THE WHEEL, READY TO MOVE YOUR CAR UPON REQUEST BETWEEN SUNRISE AND SUNSET. 
 
My suggestion is to check the front of your parking ticket for mistakes. If you find a mistake, and it is a required element, you win upon application. If not, you are left with a fine to pay and no reduction. 
 
NYC parking rules are designed to raise revenue, and are enforced literally, harshly and with no flexibility. Fire hydrants and bus stop rules are enforced harshly. Stay 15 feet from the pump. Please.  
 
Good luck. 
Posted @ Saturday, May 01, 2010 8:25 PM by Larry Berezin
This is truly outrageous. NYC DEFINITELY targets out-of-state vehicles. We were towed after we were parked 15.5 ft from a hydrant. The ticket said 6 feet! We had a tape measurer, but unfortunately no camera, so we're probably screwed. But I really wish something would be done about this disgusting targeting of out-of-state vehicles, and the outright lies of these despicable cops. Disgusting!
Posted @ Wednesday, May 05, 2010 6:05 PM by Outrageous
Outrageous, 
Bravo. Well said. I agree. I'm working on it.  
 
Are you going to fight your parking ticket?
Posted @ Saturday, May 08, 2010 9:08 PM by Larry Berezin
Hi. We are from out of state and we received a ticket about a week ago after explicitly trying to avoid one! It was Thursday night and the street we were parked on was set to be cleaned the next morning, so we decided to move our car to the other side. At that very moment there were two cops standing at the corner right in front of the spot we were trying to take. Also, they had parked one of their little vehicles in front of a fire hydrant, completely blocking it from view (We only became aware of it the next morning). So, as the cops were there chatting, we moved our car and parked on the other side, feeling content at avoiding a ticket. 
 
The next morning we see that we did in fact receive a ticket, literally minutes after we parked the car, stating that we were only 10ft away from the hydrant. The outrage here is that the cops were RIGHT there, blocking the hydrant from view, and instead of simply saying "don't park there" they opted to give us a $115 ticket minutes after we parked right in front of them. Also, I believe we were more than 15 ft away. We did not have a tape measure, but we did take a picture of the distance. 
 
Do we have grounds to contest this ticket? 
 
Thank you.
Posted @ Sunday, May 30, 2010 6:02 PM by Doubtful
Doubtful, 
So much for fair play. 
What a shame. I'm happy you weren't towed.  
 
I have beaten parking tickets under the circumstances you describe. The key ingredient is to establish where your car was parked by using the picture you took. Once you do that, you can measure the distance between you car and the pump. 
 
I've simplified matters with this explanation because there are a number of other factors at play. For example, how will you prove your picture was taken on the date your ticket was issued? How is the place of occurrence described? Among others. 
 
If you believe you're right--FIGHT. You've got nothing to lose since there is no fine reduction for a pump violation. 
 
Let us know what you decide. 
Thanks for paying us a visit and submitting a very interesting story.
Posted @ Sunday, June 06, 2010 6:54 PM by lawrence berezin
Hello and thank you for this blog. I have just received a ticket for parking 6ft from a hydrant. My tape indicated that it was a legal spot (my neighbors and I have been parking there for months with no problems). I didn't take a picture (it's dark and raining outside and I had to move my car for tomorrow's alternative side parking), however I believe I got lucky with the address shown on the ticket (Opposite 412 Kings Pl). It simply does not exist. What kind of proof/statement do you suggest I provide? 
 
Thank you in advance, 
Larisa
Posted @ Wednesday, June 09, 2010 9:51 PM by Larisa
Larisa,  
You're welcome, and thanks for your thank you for the blog. There are several ways to prove the NON-existence of an address:  
1. Address a letter to yourself at 412 Kings Place. If the address does not exist, your letter will be returned to sender, address unknown, no such number, etc. by the United States Post Office. That is all the proof you need.  
2. Or, Go to "find a sign" on our website. Scroll to the bottom of the page. You'll see a Find out Whether an address exists, with a link. Click on the link, and plug in your info, and voila. If the address doesn't exist, it will tell you.  
 
Among others.  
Good luck.  
Let me know how you make out.
Posted @ Thursday, June 10, 2010 12:47 PM by Larry Berezin
I received two tickets for parking within 15 feet of a hydrant (not purposely, I thought I was parked far enough away and there were no markings on the curb)... However, ultimately upon measuring I can't dispute that I was within 15 feet.  
 
 
 
My issue is that these tickets were for the same offense. One was issued at 5:58pm - minutes after I parked the car and went upstairs for the night - and the other was at 1:05am. I moved the car as soon as I saw the violations at about 7:00am that morning. I know legally this is permitted but is there any chance of the second violation being dropped or reduced? 
 
 
 
I already checked both tickets for mistakes/ommissions and other than the fact that they're different ticket forms with slight differences in information required I seem to be out of luck. One violation doesn't list the VIN but that isn't required, it doesn't specify 2 or 4 doors but on that version of the ticket form it doesn't seem to be required and the name of complainant is simply "Kim A." 
 
 
 
This probably won't matter either but my car is BLUE and the tickets indicate GREEN - however - upon checking my registration, it also lists the car green. Does that nulify the mistake on the tickets? 
 
 
 
One other question: can you tell me what the space for CD references? I haven't been able to find a definition of it anywhere. 
 
 
 
Thanks, 
 
Michele
Posted @ Saturday, June 12, 2010 8:21 PM by Michele
Michele 
Thanks for taking your valuable time to visit our website and pose a great question. I'm very sorry to say the second parking ticket must be issued within one hour of the first to win a dismissal of the second ticket. 
 
I once knew what CD stood for, but it's vanished without leaving a trace from my old, tired mind. I'll find out and get back to you. It is NOT a required element, though. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Thursday, June 17, 2010 12:11 PM by Larry Berezin
I was driving a commercial vehicle, and got a Fire Hydrant ticket in Manhattan, while performing a service call (Which I have the Work Order to prove). 
 
My vehicle was 15' (Measured with my feet) away from the Hydrant, but I didn't have a camera or a tape measure with me at that time. Can this ticket still be fought, even though I've left the place of occurence already?
Posted @ Tuesday, June 29, 2010 11:50 AM by Frank
Frank 
Great to hear from you, Frank. If you have no visible proof, I'm sorry to say, it will be a tough ticket to beat. 
 
You really have to make your case and then some to beat the pump. 
 
Did you check the front of your parking ticket for mistakes? If you unearth an omitted, misdescribed required element, You win, upon application. 
 
Is the place of occurrence correct? 
How about plate and body type? 
 
If I can help, please post another comment. I'll check back. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Thursday, July 01, 2010 11:43 AM by Larry Berezin
I received a ticket and the cop wrote I was 3ft from the hydrant. Using my feet as measurement I had to be at least 10ft away. I have photos, also with my foot against a drain that was between my car and the hydrant, which shows that I'm at least 4ft(the length of the drain) from the hydrant. Is it a valid defense to say since the cop, put simply, can't even measure properly, how is it even know im 15ft away? You know take away the only thing that says im guilty and thus prove im innocent.
Posted @ Tuesday, July 06, 2010 11:04 PM by Richard
Richard, 
 
We all feel your frustration. Unfortunately, the only proof that will set you free is, proof you were parked more than 15 feet from pump. As long as the warrior inserts a distance from the pump, he meets his burden of proof (according to the judges).  
 
If the warrior fails to insert a distance, you win. Accuracy doesn't count. Sorry 'bout that. 
 
Thanks for taking your valuable time to visit us. Please come back and continue to share your parking experiences. They help all of us!
Posted @ Monday, July 12, 2010 7:50 PM by lawrence berezin
Larry,  
 
I have sent you an email regarding a no standing ticket, if you have the chance please do reply.
Posted @ Wednesday, July 28, 2010 2:11 PM by peter
Larry, 
 
 
 
Your blog is the greatest thing created, that us public drivers can ask for.  
 
 
 
I have a question about inconsistency on a VC-19 parking ticket (No Standing-Bus Stop). The Place of occurence indicated as "Opposite 5618 8th Ave" and the (County) box had "K". I searched on Google Map...Street View and it showed 5618 is surely the opposite side of the Bus Stop. However, on the Bus Stop side (actual bus stop) - there are addresses (business stores) along the sidewalk (5615, 5617, 5619, etc.) Why couldn't the warrior use one of the addresses, instead of "Opposite 5618 8th Ave.) On another note, I happened to drove by that street to check out the address (5618 8th Ave.). Can I argue about the inconsistency of the exact location indicated on the tkt? Btw...the tkt copy (online) showed (N/A) in the "Exp. Date" for my (NJ) plate.  
 
 
 
Thank you in advance for your advise.
Posted @ Monday, September 20, 2010 2:30 PM by Tim
Tim, 
 
I'm blushing. Thanks very much for your kind words. They really mean a lot to me, and I'm glad you find the information helpful. 
 
A parking ticket warrior has three (3) equally O.K. ways to describe a place of occurrence; in front of, opposite of, and a detailed description ( looks like directions to a pirate's buried treasure). The choice is the warriors, and must be accurate. If accurate, we can't win a fight about the choice made by the warrior. 
 
NJ plates do not display the month and year on the plate; and NJ owners are not required to display the registration sticker on the windshield. So, NS or NA is acceptable.  
 
I'm sorry I don't have any better advice for you on this one. Please visit us again.
Posted @ Tuesday, September 21, 2010 11:00 AM by Larry Berezin
Tim, 
 
Some great questions.  
You can fight a NYC parking ticket up until the time a judgment is entered (100 days from issuance). Once a judgment is issued, you are required to file a Request to Vacate Judgment application and persuade a judge your failure to respond constitutes excusable neglect; and you must demonstrate a substantial defense to the parking crime. Not easy burdens to meet. 
 
I've defended parking tickets for out-of-state residents who claim never to have been in NYC. I've won some and lost some. There are no rhyme or reasons to the decisions, except fund raising for NYC. 
 
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and opinions!
Posted @ Tuesday, September 21, 2010 2:49 PM by Larry Berezin
Thanks for the response and comments.  
 
 
 
What has this city turned into? Seems like our local gov't is getting corrupted and abusing their authorities to prey on innocent citizens. I used to live in Astoria, Brooklyn-NY for 20+ yrs. and back in the those days - law enforcers were more courteous. Even with T/A - they would ask you to move your car, if you were parking illegally. Nowadays, they would drive their car or little wagon and BLOCK you in and write you a ticket. NO more courtesy or warnings. Can NYC actually garnishes your wages/salary if you refuse to pay the ticket, even if it's a mistake and didn't get dismissed from an appeal? 
 
 
 
NYC should have a new slogan "The city that SCAMS public drivers on tickets" 
 
 
 
I hope that all the people that joined this blog would be more vigilant when drive into NYC. 
 
 
 
Peace to all...
Posted @ Tuesday, September 21, 2010 4:15 PM by Tim
Received a ticket for parking too close to a hydrant. It says 7 feet but I was at least 13. I park there all the time because it is directly in front of my house. The ticket reads 'opposite' my house address...since there is no hydrant opposite my address can this be a defense? I have tried on another occasion to do the measuring tape and photo defense but I lost. They said I could have moved the vehicle back to take the picture. Help...and thank you!
Posted @ Sunday, October 03, 2010 10:10 AM by Linda
Linda, 
 
Congratulations, you are a WINNER! 
 
The place of occurrence is a required element, and must be entered accurately for the parking ticket warrior to win. As you correctly stated, if the warrior inserted "opposite" your home address, and there is no fire hydrant within 15 feet in either direction, the warrior blundered. 
 
I understand (hate it, though), when a judge accuses you of moving the car when you took the photo. But, he/she can't accuse you of moving the fire hydrant.  
 
I would suggest presenting overlapping photographs of the entire block, with particular attention paid to the area fifteen feet in either direction from the address entered on your ticket by the warrior. 
 
Just a note...It doesn't matter if the warrior inserts the wrong distance from your car to the pump, you have to persuade his/her Honor you parked more than fifteen feet away; or be able to assert the Elvis Presley Defense. 
 
Good luck. 
Let us know how you do. 
Posted @ Monday, October 04, 2010 4:40 PM by lawrence berezin
Hello,  
 
I parked my car too close to a hydrant overnight, and I was issued not one, but two tickets. They tickets were issued only 3.5 hrs apart from each other, and this seems a bit excessive. Are there any limits to how often they can ticket your car for the same violation or am I stuck? 
 
Thank you, 
H
Posted @ Wednesday, October 06, 2010 5:05 PM by Hannah
Hannah, 
 
I am very sorry to report a warrior may issue a parking ticket every 61 minutes for the same violation in the same parking space. Please check the front of your parking ticket for mistakes. 
If a required element (mistake) is omitted, misdescribed or illegible, you win upon application. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Thursday, October 07, 2010 9:17 PM by Larry Berezin
How bad is this scenario: An out-of-state is parked by a fire hydrant due to unclear pavement markers. The first ticket was issued at 3am, and the 2nd at 7am. The car got towed at 7am. Fees in excess of both tickets were paid to retreive the car - Can one use the fees already paid as a means of reducing the fine? 
 
Thanks - P.
Posted @ Sunday, October 10, 2010 1:56 PM by Pelo
Pelo, 
 
 
 
Bad AND Sad. I'm really sorry to hear about your parking nightmare. 
 
 
 
Your fees cannot be applied to reduce your fine...Sorry. 
 
 
 
Under NYC parking rules, there are NO pavement markings to designate the distance you are permitted to park from a pump. It is fifteen feet in either direction; unless you or another licensed driver remain behind the wheel of the car between sunrise and sunset, ready willing and able to move the vehicle upon request to do so. 
 
 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Sunday, October 10, 2010 2:20 PM by lawrence berezin
Larry, 
 
I finally received a response back from DOF Adjudication Division on 10/14/2010. What I am puzzled about this response was that there was no reason/comment whether my Hearing By Mail was dimissed or found guilty. 
 
All I saw on the letter was a statement "We received your request for a hearing by mail on the summons shown below". "Based on the violation described, we are offering you the opportunity to pay a reduced fine in the amount shown ($90). If you accept this reduction offer, RETURN THE COUPON with your payment by the due date above (11/12/10). If you pay the reduced fine, a judge will not review your case." 
 
To me it seemed that they didn't even read my letter of defense or reviewed my support documents. Probably they just did a computer generated response with a Reduced Fine offer. I don't feel this is RIGHT and I want to reject the reduced fine offer and appeal to have my case to be reviewed again. And this time I have a letter statement from one of the dentist patient that acknowledged my presence during the time indicated by the letter from the dentist office. As I mentioned previously - the woman that vouchered my presence at the dentist office, she's an employee of NYC DA office. 
 
Please advise how do I go about fighting this ticket for a full dismissal - when I attested that I was nowhere at the accused location. And I did not lend my vehicle to anyone to drive while my wife and I were in the dentist office. I drove straight to the dentist office from NJ, without stopping anywhere. Thanks for your help.
Posted @ Thursday, October 14, 2010 10:01 AM by Timothy
Fear not, Sir Tim...Your quest for justice is still in the journey to a judge stage. The letter you received from the Black Knight's functionary is a standard, form letter that is sent to every knight who fights a NYC parking ticket.  
 
You are being offered a reduced fine in lieu of a hearing,(a plea bargain). It is a voluntary offer. A response is not necessary. Your case will be sent to a judge for disposition. 
 
Continued good fortune. 
 
Posted @ Thursday, October 14, 2010 10:35 AM by Larry Berezin
Larry, 
 
Thank you for the quick response. I assume that once 11/12/10 date is passed - it will be "judgement day". I just hope that they wouldn't impose additional penalties onto the tkt.  
 
Should I mail in the statement letter from the woman that acknowledged my presence at the dentist office? I want to add more shield to my defense - before giving the ALJ a chance to question about the whereabout of my vehicle or if I lent the vehicle to someone; while I was in the dentist office. I would much want this fight to be over quickly, rather than submitting an appeal and go through the whole hearing process again. From the date when I first received the NOOS in the mail - it has been stressing me out in my mind. And I get worried of having my vehicle towed when I am in NY. As a matter of fact - I had a dream last night that my SUV got towed when I parked between other cars and I tried to run after the guy to show him that my case is in "hearing pending". But he took off so fast that I couldn't catch him on foot. It may sound silly - but it's true and I am not pulling your leg and joking. 
 
Thank you for your words of wisdom..."Guardian of Camelot" :)
Posted @ Thursday, October 14, 2010 12:31 PM by Timothy
Tim, 
 
Once your parking ticket defense is received by the DOF, additional fines are put on hold. I wouldn't bother submitting additional proofs because they'll never reach your initial submission. 
 
"Hearing pending" parking tickets do NOT increase the chances of being towed.  
 
You are fighting the good fight. Camelot wasn't built in a day.  
We are all proud of your efforts.
Posted @ Thursday, October 14, 2010 1:05 PM by Larry Berezin
Nuno, 
 
You are an official member of the NYC driving public. Welcome aboard. I'm sorry for your rude greeting by one of our parking ticket warriors. What would a visit to our fair city be without meeting up with a warrior in full battle dress. 
 
If the warrior's description of the place of occurrence brings you to a spot where there is no fire hydrant within 15 feet of either side of the parking space, you win! 
Your proof gets a little tricky. 
 
I'm happy to take a look at your parking ticket online, if you provide me with the summons number (10 digit number on ticket); or let me know the exact wording of the place of occurrence, not just the 80 feet part. 
 
I'm happy to help. 
Posted @ Monday, October 18, 2010 6:32 PM by Larry Berezin
Thanks for the reply, Larry. 
The exact wording for the address is: 
"E/S Front St 
80ft S/of Wall St" 
I'm happy to send you the ticket number - is there a private way to do so? 
Thanks again!
Posted @ Monday, October 18, 2010 7:44 PM by Nuno
Nuno, 
 
Good afternoon. I think you are on the right road to victory. You may wish to Check out the Parking Sign Locator page on our website. Click on the large parking sign and you will be whisked to the DOT website. Try plugging in Front Street, Wall Street and the side street closest to the evil pump.  
 
Try to match the parking signs pictured on Google Maps with the parking signs shown on Locate A Sign tool and you'll have the distances from the curb.  
 
Maybe if you can demonstrate a parking sign closest to the hydrant is more than 80 feet South of Wall Street, you'll have the proper proof, without returning to NYC for a measurement. What a pain. 
 
Give it a try, and let me know how you do. 
Good luck. 
Posted @ Tuesday, October 19, 2010 2:25 PM by Larry Berezin
Just a comment by a European who lives in NYC. If parking 15 feet away from a hydrant is considered such an important safety issue by the city of NY, then WTF don't they put clear markings on the sidewalk so that drivers can know exactly where it is legal to park? So many times I have been in situations where I am not sure whether it is ok to park or not, and even had long discussions with other drivers about whether we are 15 feet or more away. Sorry for being cynical, but isn't this whole rule just so subjective that it could be considered a deliberate revenue raising policy? Putting it another way, if NYC spent the small amount of money to paint 15 foot markers by every hydrant, how much revenue would they lose in parking fines? I don't understand how an advanced country like USA can have such a stupid rule!
Posted @ Saturday, October 23, 2010 6:36 AM by Nosy Parker
I was parked approx 5 ft from a hydrant but was under the impression as it is stated "unless otherwise indicated by signs" that a alternate side parking sign pointing away from the hydrant meant all areas ahead of that sign. The hydrant was fully accessible if needed by FDNY, they could even park behind me and extend there hoses to the hydrant. I sent a dispute in and declared my case and it came back guilty. I do see that I didnt have a dated time picture camera, nor was the address visible of the other persons home because it was blocked by trees she has in the yard. What shall I do?
Posted @ Thursday, October 28, 2010 11:26 PM by Louis
Louis, 
 
Thanks for taking your valuable time to join our conversation. Parking Ticket Warriors and Judges alike are very unforgiving about pump violations. If you cannot prove you parked more than 15 feet from the fire hydrant, you may wish to pay the fine before penalties are assessed. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Friday, October 29, 2010 7:11 PM by Larry Berezin
i got a ticket for parking next to fire hydrant - i didnt even see the hydrant as the homeowner painted it the same color as their mailbox, that stands next to hydrant. when backing in to space, the hydrant didnt catch my eye and there was no yellow markings on sidewalk. any chance of fighting this ticket?
Posted @ Sunday, October 31, 2010 8:14 PM by michelle
Michelle, 
 
Great to have you join the conversation! I'm sorry to report, your defense won't work against a fire hydrant violation. Judges are very, very strict, intractable, unbending, and worse when it comes to pump violations; as opposed to their normal very strict and unbending for all the other approximately 90 parking violations. 
 
Pump defenses include: 
1. Proving you were parked more than 15 feet from the pump; 
2. Leaving someone in your vehicle, old enough to move the car with keys in the ignition between sunrise and sunset. 
 
No yellow lines or curb markings are required for fire hydrants, bus stops, etc.  
 
Good luck. 
 
Posted @ Monday, November 01, 2010 1:58 PM by Larry Berezin
Hi, 
 
 
 
I went to pick up my recently injured daughter from her work and as I watched her struggle through the doors on both crutches with tremendous difficulties, I instinctively got up to help her, leaving the car at the curb side where it says “No Standing Except Trucks Loading and Unloading.” As Within minutes of helping her get to the car, I saw the police giving me a ticket and he didn't even listen to my explanation of situation. What are traffic laws that would help me fight the ticket in this case? I have my daughter's Emergency Room visit to show that she was injured at the time and had great difficulties moving around. Would New Yorker courts be so insensitive to families and disabled people? 
 
 
 
Your help is appreciated.
Posted @ Monday, November 15, 2010 9:04 PM by Eileen
This is a perfect example of what has happened to traffic enforcement in New York City. I do not believe that what happened to Eileen would have happened years ago before ticket quotas. My suggestion would be to do what I did when I got a ticket because I left my car briefly to bring my groceries into my apartment. At the suggestion of police at my local precinct I pleaded Not Guilty and wrote a letter stating that it would be a real hardship for me to carry my groceries all the way from where I usually find parking. The ticket was dismissed. But I was not so lucky when I pleaded Not Guilty to a fraudulent ticket for parking 5 feet from a hydrant. I had parked over 15 feet away. The system is corrupt and crimes are being committed against the public on a regular basis. The City Council and the press should be more involved in exposing this horror. In my neighborhood I have noticed that people are parking 20 or more feet from hydrants. This indicates to me that motorists are fearful of being victimized. 
 
Good luck Eileen. If you live in the city writing a letter to your City Councilperson and newspapers would help us all move in a more positive direction.
Posted @ Monday, November 15, 2010 10:27 PM by Norman
Norman, 
From the heart...Bravo!
Posted @ Tuesday, November 16, 2010 8:01 AM by Larry Berezin
Summoned and towed at fire hydrant. 
Denied explanation by DOT. 
DOT replied vehicle parked at hydrant, less then 15 Feet from bollard.
Posted @ Monday, November 22, 2010 11:27 AM by Robert Bianco
What is bollard? 
 
 
 
Posted @ Wednesday, November 24, 2010 9:45 PM by Norman
A bollard is a short vertical post. Originally it only meant a post[1] used on a quay for mooring. The word now also describes a variety of structures to control or direct road traffic, such as posts arranged in a line to obstruct the passage of motor vehicles.[2] In addition, bollards are used in the lighting industry to describe short post like light fixtures. 
 
The term may be related to bole, meaning a tree trunk.[3]
Posted @ Thursday, November 25, 2010 10:17 AM by Larry Berezin
50 pages of your blogs here and you all fail to say the obvious: Tickest through the NYC PVB are the most efficient tax collection organization in NY. They collect and use the money to pay salaries and "other" and it its money used to balance city budgets. .. tickets are a part of the NYC/NYS kangaroo court taxation system. Almost never is proof of your violation submitted by the PVB nor the department of sanitation regarding their summonses. No Proof!!!! it confounds the healthy mind that the plaintiffs never have proof. In 2010 a simple camera phone device as part of the ticket givers tool kit would give the plaintiff all they need to end the argument.It gives them proof they dont currently submit. that said, the defendant could use the same tools and submit the result with a witness who has signed the affidavit ( which should actually be in a phone app too! 
Apple store has an I fone app now that uses a virtual measuring device within the viewfinder to capture a shot of your car and the hydrant with a ruler in the picture. also there is another app. that uses a sonar-sound- much like auto focus to tell you EXACTLY how far you are from a specific object before you are done parking. These should be in the hands of both plaintiff and defendant and should be required proof at least - accepted proof so our city of morons and liars and ill equipped public workers and under trained assholes can appear to be part of a solution and not a part of the problem, but that would undermine the hand out jobs they have been given to generate cash for the city. 
the court system requires US to be exact. Pictures that are not qualifiable are really NOT good evidence and the low level judges use that against us as a personal bonus tool when it comes to judging your case. it is likely that they make more money if the city makes money. All hydrants should have a curb marker at 15 feet . A bright yellow tile that NEVER wears out. everyone should be able to see it and no one should try to fool with it. a phone foto of the marker and you car might help - dated and submitted with an affidvit- which costs time and money ( and thats really the fuck of it) No one wants to spend their time or money - to prevail - especially when you KNOW you have parked correctly.
Posted @ Friday, November 26, 2010 6:28 PM by neil
I parked in front of a MTA, New york City Transit Dry Standpipe, and got a ticket (code 40). I parked there before and didn't get a ticket, also people park there all the time and don't get tickets. Were they right for giving me that ticket?
Posted @ Thursday, December 16, 2010 5:10 AM by Luis
Luis, 
Good evening. Great question. I would argue the standpipe is not a "fire hydrant" referred to by the VC 40. Submit a photograph and hope for the best.  
 
This is my first "standpipe" VC 40. 
Let us know how you do. 
Good luck!
Posted @ Thursday, December 16, 2010 5:24 PM by Larry Berezin
I would like to find out how i could do a counter claim on appeal of ticket to a higher court. I do not trust administrative hearings and want a real court to hear my claim. I want to file a counter claim with my appeal.  
Thank you
Posted @ Thursday, December 16, 2010 10:10 PM by Yuri
Yuri, 
Thanks for visiting our website and posing a great question. Despite your distrust for administrative hearings, you are still required to follow the yellow brick road: 
 
1. Fight--lose 
2. Appeal within 30 days--lose 
3. File an Article 78 Hearing Request with the NY Supreme Court. 
 
You are not permitted to stray from this path. 
 
Good luck. 
Posted @ Friday, December 17, 2010 12:51 PM by Larry Berezin
Sergio, 
A very, very heartfelt congratulations on the birth of your first daughter. My first daughter, Julie, is now 29 years old; and there is nothing in the universe as wonderful as the relationship between a father and his daughter.  
 
You were blessed on that day; and you can beat or ignore your parking ticket. If the plate is wrong, you win. You can fight the parking ticket by pointing out the mistake and enclosing a copy of your vehicle registration. 
 
You are a double winner. The make of your vehicle must be entered correctly on your parking ticket. If not, you win by pointing out the mistake and again, enclosing a copy of your registration.  
 
Please email us a picture of your daughter. Can't wait to meet her. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Thursday, January 06, 2011 6:32 PM by Larry Berezin
HELP!!!! I recvd 2 tickets for parking too close to a fire hydrant 12/12/10 in the Bronx while visting from Virginia. The first was issued @ 8:48am and the second was issued @ 8:56am the same morning. This isnt legal right? Can I get the second one dismissed? If so how?
Posted @ Thursday, January 06, 2011 9:22 PM by Monique
Monique, 
I'm sorry for your rude treatment at the hands of man-eating parking ticket warriors. As a general policy, if you are issued two parking tickets for the same violation, in the same space, within one hour of each other, a parking ticket judge will dismiss the second parking ticket. Some judges will extend the time in between a warrior feeding frenzy to 3 hours. I suggest defending the second parking ticket on that basis, even though the second ticket was issued a little more than one hour from the first. 
 
Also, check the front of both parking tickets for mistakes. Does a VA plate or windshield display the month/year your registration expires? If so, did the warriors insert the exact month and year in the EXP box?; or did they insert NA or NS? 
 
If NA or NS, you win again.  
If any other required elements are omitted, misdescribed, or illegible, such as make, plate type, place of occurrence, etc., you win upon application. 
 
Good luck. 
 
 
Posted @ Friday, January 07, 2011 10:47 AM by Larry Berezin
This is great! So I can get the 2nd ticket dismissed. Sorry to be a bother, but how should I go about that? I am out-of-state, should I do it online or come back to the NYC? which one will get the best resluts? also, the 2nd ticket was issued 8 minutes after the 1st one, not a hour as you stated, does this help my case? can you take a look at my tickets for mistakes i have no clue what should be on it? Thanks!!!
Posted @ Friday, January 07, 2011 4:10 PM by Monique
Monique, 
Good evening. Absolutely no bother. Never, ever fight a NYC parking ticket online. Your time is far too valuable to waste it returning to NYC, sitting in line, and waiting for a parking ticket judge to give you 2 minutes of her time. 
 
I suggest fighting your parking ticket by mail. Submit a respectful letter directed to a judge, and explain you received two parking tickets, for the same offense, while your car occupied the same space. The first at ____ A.M., and the second at ___A.M. Ask the judge to dismiss the second parking ticket and explain your intention to pay the first ticket. 
 
Send your defense package by certified mail, RRR. Make sure to include the summons number of the first parking ticket in your letter, along with the second summons number. 
 
Before you prepare your letter, I'm happy to check your parking ticket for mistakes. Please post your summons numbers; or send me an email with your summons numbers if you'd prefer some privacy. 
 
Let us know the outcome. 
Good luck. 
Posted @ Friday, January 07, 2011 5:28 PM by Larry Berezin
Hello, 
 
We were in Manhattan last night and parked about 8 feet away from a fire hydrant after almost 30 minutes of circling around a lot of blocks, by which time it started snowing and the city being filthy and lot of parking spots taken away by snow piles! We parked for a few hours overnight and were slapped with a $115 ticket...can we contest this? Should we try to get it reduced? Should we just pay it?
Posted @ Sunday, January 30, 2011 12:23 PM by rmk
rmk, 
Good evening. I'm sorry a parking ticket ruined your visit to Manhattan. If you parked within 15 feet of a fire hydrant, you are toast; unless there is a mistake on the front of your parking ticket. Such as, make, expiration date, plate type, body type, place of occurrence.  
 
If no mistakes, you may wish to pay your parking ticket. Unfortunately, there is no fine reduction for a fire hydrant violation. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Sunday, January 30, 2011 8:13 PM by Larry Berezin
Hey Larry, 
 
Great blog! It is completely useful and detailed. 
 
I received a parking ticket for parking 8 feet away from a hydrant. 
 
Unfortunately, I did not see the ticket but when I was away from the place I parked and did not measure or take the pictures as you suggest. 
 
However, I would like to either dispute the ticket or at least get the fine reduction. 
 
I noticed that you suggested a person from Canada to plead not guilty and then pay the reduced fine, but your last comment says that there is no reduction for parking by a hydrant. I believe this has changed. 
 
Additionally, my parking ticket says N/A in the EXP DATE box and my car has a big sticker displayed in the windshield with the expiration date of my registration. 
 
I live in NJ and my car has NJ plates. 
 
Thank you, 
 
Arturo
Posted @ Monday, January 31, 2011 1:49 PM by Art
I parked on 6th Ave. at night in front of the B of A building by 42-43rd st. There was a hydrant and I didn't know about measuring so I didn't do it. 
 
However, the hydrant was blocked behind a "pylon" that blocks vehicle access to the building. You can't even see the hydrant from up the block. 
 
Is there a law about the hydrant being visible?
Posted @ Monday, January 31, 2011 3:47 PM by Edward
Edward, 
Good evening. 
Thanks for taking your valuable time to visit our website and share your parking experience. 
 
Please don't shoot the messenger. Parking ticket judges consistently rule against a pump being visible as an element of the parking violation. For example, they have found against the driving public when a pump is covered by garbage bags, snow, or a construction garage can. Makes no sense, but it seems to be the custom. 
 
Since there is no reduction, you may wish to fight your violation; as long as you have a great photo showing the fire hydrant is invisible. 
 
I am rooting for you. 
Please let me know what you decide to do. 
Posted @ Monday, January 31, 2011 7:07 PM by Larry Berezin
Got a ticket in Dec just b/4 Xmas. 
The ticket said parked 10feet away 
Great blog! You saved me $105. All I presented at the hearing was a couple of pictures and explained that I was parked 16 feet from the hydrant. The officer looked at the pics and said that the agent should have measured the distance and taken pictures, since he did not do that he has to use my pics as evidence and dismissed the ticket. The whole process took 5 minutes. Thanks again for your advice. If you are right don't be scared to fight.
Posted @ Wednesday, February 02, 2011 12:20 PM by Ed
Ed, 
Great news on a not-so-great day. 
Thanks for sharing your good fortune with us.  
 
We are thrilled for you. 
Nicely done.
Posted @ Wednesday, February 02, 2011 7:33 PM by Larry Berezin
My car was impounded for parking too close to the hydrant, so I was unable to gather evidence to dispute the ticket. When I parked the car I used the "heal to toe" method to estimate my distance from the rear tire to the hydrant. I was 16 "feet" away. The ticket said that I was 4 feet away, which is a gross underestimate. Am I guilty? Do I dispute? Please help.
Posted @ Tuesday, February 08, 2011 3:18 PM by pk
PK, 
Good evening. Great to hear from you. 
Heal to toe is a good method to judge the distance from a fire hydrant, except: 
1. You have no proof of the distance you can present to a parking ticket judge; and 
 
2. The measurement is from the rear bumper of your car to the hydrant; not the wheel 
 
Unless there is a mistake on the front of the ticket, such as, make, expiration date, body type, plate type, place of occurrence, this ticket is going to be tough to beat. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Tuesday, February 08, 2011 5:59 PM by Larry Berezin
Leni, 
Did you take pictures of the snow covered hydrant?
Posted @ Thursday, February 10, 2011 5:46 AM by lawrence berezin
I think the officer made a mistake with the plate number - a T instead of a J. Is there a way to check what the DOF's record shows without telling them my name?
Posted @ Monday, February 14, 2011 8:49 AM by Ben
Ben, 
Good morning. The best way to check without shooting yourself in the foot is to check on the DOF website. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Monday, February 14, 2011 9:45 AM by Larry Berezin
Larry, 
 
I called DOF and they said since it was handwritten ticket it wouldn't be on website for 3 weeks. I'll check then and keep you posted through your blog. Thanks, Ben
Posted @ Tuesday, February 15, 2011 9:11 AM by ben
Thanks, Ben!
Posted @ Tuesday, February 15, 2011 9:22 AM by Larry Berezin
Hi,  
 
In my neighbourhood there is a n.y.c.t wet stand pipe which is not a Fire hydrant. For years me and everybody as parked in front if that stand pipe and no one has gottan a ticket until I woke up this morning. What should I do? I'm going to fight it but do you think that that ticket id wrong to be given.  
 
Thanks
Posted @ Saturday, February 19, 2011 11:44 AM by darriel
Darriel, 
Good afternoon. Thanks for sharing your parking ticket experience; especially one as unique as you described.  
 
According to Wikipedia,  
"A standpipe is a type of rigid water piping which is built into multi-story buildings in a vertical position, to which fire hoses can be connected, allowing manual application of water to the fire. Within buildings standpipes thus serve the same purpose as fire hydrants." 
 
The parking rule prohibiting stopping,standing, or parking within 15 feet of a fire hydrant does not prohibit parking in front of a wet standpipe; despite the fact that a pump and standpipe serve the same purpose. 
 
In my humble opinion, you are right, and should absolutely fight your parking ticket. Please be sure to present the proper proof, properly. If the NYC Council intended to prohibit stopping, standing or parking in front of a standpipe, they should have said so; and they did not. 
Posted @ Saturday, February 19, 2011 1:04 PM by Larry Berezin
So...I think I got a parking ticket when I was in Brooklyn this weekend. I say think, because I was driving back to Virginia when I turned my windshield wipers on (somewhere in the swamps of Jersey) and saw a white sheet of paper go flying off my windshield on to the NJ Turnpike. I'm assuming it was tucked under the wiper on the passenger side, out of my line of vision until I turned on the wiper. 
 
I think I may have parked too close to a hydrant. I didn't know about the 15 ft. limit and, taking a clue from the car behind the hydrant, I parked about 5 ft. away (there were metal poles standing on either side of the hydrant that I assumed indicated the "no parking" area around the hydrant. 
 
Anyway, how do I pay a ticket I don't have in my posession? I found the city's online ticket search engine and so far there is no ticket using my VA plate number. Granted, it's only been two days.  
 
How long does it take for a violation to show up in the system, and am I going to have a problem determining the validity of the ticket if I don't have an original copy? 
 
Thanks!
Posted @ Monday, March 21, 2011 8:03 PM by Allison
Allison, 
Good morning. 
If your parking ticket was printed/scanned, it generally takes about 5-7 days to rear its ugly orange head on the DOF website. 
 
If your parking ticket was handwritten, it will take much longer.  
 
Since you don't know which epistle you received, I'd begin checking after five days. 
 
You may wish to sign up for Parkzing on our website. It's a free tool that will send you an email message when your parking ticket appears. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Tuesday, March 22, 2011 8:08 AM by Larry Berezin
I just got a ticket for being parked in front of a hydrant that has a sign on it saying it's out of service. I figured it was safe to park there since it's out of service.
Posted @ Wednesday, June 15, 2011 7:05 AM by lis
lis, 
Good afternoon. 
Thanks for taking your valuable time to visit our website. Excellent question.  
 
The general rule is you are prohibited from parking within 15 feet of a fire hydrant, whether it is broken or not. However, I'm intrigued by the fact there was a sign. 
 
Can you email me a photograph of the sign? Looking forward to your reply. 
 
Posted @ Wednesday, June 15, 2011 2:00 PM by Larry Berezin
I can't figure out how to upload the picture to the website. I would be happy to send you the pictures if you would direct me as to how. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Posted @ Thursday, June 16, 2011 7:24 AM by lis
lis, 
 
Hi. You can email the photo to me at: 
 
nyparkingticket@optonline.net 
 
Thanks. 
Posted @ Thursday, June 16, 2011 1:26 PM by Larry Berezin
I just wanted to pass along a word on how I got a fire hydrant ticket thrown out the other day. This happened in Forest Hills, and being from upstate, I had not clue about the 15 feet requirement. The ticket merely said 5 Feet from Hydrant. I thought this meant I was within five feet, so I got a measuring tape and a camera and documented that it was 6 feet, 8 inches from the hydrant. After I looked up the rule, I decided to plead my ignorance anyway. I submitted my defense online, saying the ticket was mis-stated and that there were no signs or paint on the curb indicating the no parking zone. I just got an email back saying the judge threw it out! The violation decisions reads "defective summons warrants dismissal. Not on the merits." I guess the moral of the story is to argue ANYTHING on the ticket that is not accurate.
Posted @ Tuesday, October 18, 2011 7:57 AM by Phil
Hi Larry, I got a ticket saying '0 feet from hydrate' , I had no idea what does this mean. My car was 4 feet from hydrate, and I had no idea about the rule. So should I pay the ticket? Thanks
Posted @ Sunday, October 30, 2011 10:54 AM by LEI
Phil, 
 
Hi. 
Sorry it took me so long to visit your comment. I'm getting old, and missed a few comments on this post. My bad. 
 
Congratulations for your win.  
 
As I hear every Sunday from our gaggle of NFL coaches, a win is a win.  
 
The message the parking ticket judge's decision sent us is the parking ticket was defective. In other words, a required element was omitted, inaccurate, or illegible requiring a dismissal of your ticket. It is the policy of the DOF hearings unit to check all tickets for defects; although most defects have to be proven by the parking ticket victim. 
 
I guess I take away a different moral from your story. Always, every time,check for mistakes on the front of the ticket. If none, find a defense that beats the parking crime. If none, apply for a reduced fine (where applicable).  
 
When you're right-Fight; and don't park within 15 feet of a fire hydrant. Bad karma. 
 
 
 
Posted @ Monday, October 31, 2011 7:07 PM by Larry Berezin
I received a 0 Feet from Hydrant "No driver no permit" while I was sitting in the car with my 2 babies.  
 
When I noticed him, he was writing the ticket already. 
 
How do I fight it. 
 
Thanks, 
Chris
Posted @ Tuesday, November 01, 2011 2:24 PM by chris
con't from above post: 
 
I went out and asked him what was he doing. He ignored me then handed me the ticket after he was done.
Posted @ Tuesday, November 01, 2011 2:25 PM by chris
HI I just received two fire hydrant code 40 tickets, on seperate days. One on my car the other on my husband' in front of our house. One tickets says in front of my address and the other says opposite my neighbor's address across the street from me. Oneticket says 4 ft away the other says 3ft away. I am clearly in my driveway, blocking my driveway not the fire hyrant that i not located in front of my house, it is closer to my neighbor's house. I am going to fight this ticket on person tomorrow, what should I do> Because we are talking about $230 now! Thanks
Posted @ Tuesday, November 29, 2011 8:32 PM by Anna
Anna, 
 
Good afternoon. 
You must persuade a parking ticket judge that your car wasn't parked within 15 feet of the fire hydrant. 
 
Your starting point is the place of occurrence entered on your parking ticket. If you can demonstrate there is no fire hydrant within 15 feet of the place of occurrence, you're a winner. 
 
You may wish to take your trusty camera and tape measure and go to work. 
 
Good luck.
Posted @ Wednesday, November 30, 2011 12:41 PM by Larry Berezin
Hi, 
 
I just read this whole blog and I find the quality of response very impressive. 
 
I had two tickets for staying 6 feet from a fire hydrant yesterday. 
 
My car is a rental with plates from NJ but on the plate type it states PAS instead of OMS (for rental cars), also on the body type, it states 4DSD which I don't understand... 
Can I fight those TWO tickets? 
 
Thanks! 
 
Jean
Posted @ Thursday, January 19, 2012 12:28 PM by Jean
Hi, 
 
I received two tickets staying 6 feet from a fire hydrant... 
 
My plates are from Jersey but my car is a rental and on the Plate type it states PAS instead of OMS (for rental). 
 
Is that sufficient to fight or am I down $230? 
 
Thanks!
Posted @ Friday, January 20, 2012 8:07 AM by Jean
Jean, 
 
Good morning. 
Thanks for your kind words. They're much appreciated. 
 
We have initiated a new service, "Larry's Advice." It's almost free. 
 
The information you need to fight your parking ticket is contained in the blog, if you don't mind doing a little research. 
 
Otherwise, I am happy to help you formulate a defense to your parking tickets. Please check out "Larry's Advice," and call me if you'd like me to work with you. 
 
Good luck. 
 
PS...My apologies for missing yesterday's comment. I am not aging gracefully.
Posted @ Friday, January 20, 2012 8:29 AM by Larry Berezin
Hi Larry, 
 
I posted a comment on your site yesterday, but I cannot seem to find it!  
Basically, I received 2 parking tickets in 2 days for being too close to a fire hydrant. I didn't have time for pictures or a tape measure, as I was in a hurry. But I contend that I was NOT too close. 
 
Now, my car was parked in the same spot for both days, but the tickets show strangely different locations: one says W/S Whitney Ave, 20ft S/ of Forley St. The other states N/S of Whitney Ave, 40ft W/ of Forley St. How can I be on both the North and the West side of a single street?! One ticket lists my car as Silver, the other Grey, but I don't think that matters. They both say Body Type: SUBN, when it's a Ford Escape (small mini-SUV). They were issued under different precints numbers, as well. I have out of state plates (I'm here on a work assignment). 
 
My question is, do I have a case? I would gladly pay for your "Full Service" Fight, if you believe so. I don't see a way to contact you on the site in order to set that up. I don't merely want your advice, I would like to pay for the full service option...IF I have a shot. Otherwise, I will have to bite the bullet on $230 worth of tickets (and the $70 I received yesterday...don't even ask!). Please advise! 
 
Heather
Posted @ Saturday, January 21, 2012 7:01 PM by Heather
Heather, 
 
Good morning. 
I apologize for your disappearing comment. Wow, getting old is scary! 
 
Heather, I'm happy to help you. Please feel free to give me a telephone call at 800.249.5048 at your convenience. If I'm unable to pick-up when you call, please leave a message and I promise to call you back when I return to the office. 
 
Thank you for your perseverance! I'm looking forward to speaking with you about beating your evil, orange, epistles.
Posted @ Monday, January 23, 2012 8:22 AM by Larry Berezin
I have a parking ticket that states Na/Na/NANA under the expiration date. Please can someone tell me what that means. Thank you
Posted @ Tuesday, January 24, 2012 6:26 AM by Tamara
Tamara, 
 
Good morning. 
I'd love to view this parking ticket. Please email it to me at nyparkingticket@optonline.net or fax it to me at 800.313.1092. 
 
I'm happy to answer your question after looking at the ticket. 
Thanks.
Posted @ Tuesday, January 24, 2012 8:36 AM by Larry Berezin
I posted something on Tuesday but it hasn't been added to your blog. Do you know if you received it?  
 
 
 
Thank you.
Posted @ Thursday, January 26, 2012 10:09 AM by Joshua
Thank you so much for all the help, it was worth every penny! 
 
Learning how to fight two $115 tickets is priceless! 
 
Thank you!
Posted @ Thursday, January 26, 2012 2:02 PM by Jean
Post Comment
Name
 *
Email
 *
Website (optional)
Comment
 *

Allowed tags: <a> link, <b> bold, <i> italics